Goldfellow.com displays a BBB Accredited Business logo on their website, but also has numerous customer complaints showing on major search engine directories. Their site’s copy clearly stresses that they offer safety, reliability, fast payments and that they pay up to 3X more than their competitors “that seems unproven”. However, they are a major buyer of precious metals who have been in the gold jewelry business for 30+ years.

What They Buy – Like almost every buyer in today’s online gold market, Goldfellow.com will purchase all kinds of gold, sterling silver and platinum items based upon precious metal content, current spot market price and total quantity received. They also buy through unspecified ‘Gold Party’ events.
Free Mailer – The company offers customers their FREE Track-Pak mailer which contains a pre-paid FedEx air bill that includes insurance for up to $1,000.
How They Price It – The Goldfellow.com website features a chart showing the prices they will pay for gold items based upon gold content in pennyweights, quantity received and current market price. This chart does not reflect what they pay for Sterling Silver or Platinum. The chart also shows what they will pay for very small amounts less than 1 oz.
Fast Payments – Payments are promised within 24 hours of receiving items for assay, but frequently require longer. This is mentioned on some of the Internet complaints found.
Satisfaction Guarantee – Goldfellow.com states that only they guarantee highest payments, fastest payouts and free FedEx shipping. This is certainly not the case as blind tests have repeatedly shown that other buyers make the same claim.